Why is cannibalism taboo reddit The line of thinking is that cannibalism would facilitate murder, becomes cannibalism obviously requires a dead human -- how that dead human is acquired is up in the air. Subreddit dedicated to the holiday Hallowe'en And the comments also made me realize why cannibalism is so closely associated with murder: we don't eat farm meat that's died of natural causes, we eat freshly killed farm meat. Explain Like I'm Five is the best forum and archive on the internet for layperson-friendly… Cannibalism is highly unacceptable and taboo for all regions and species besides some animals that aren't considered an intelligent species. All that said, in extreme circumstances, many people agree cannibalism is justified. Upon looking at the other comments on this thread it’s apparent to me you asked this simply so you could argue/inject the low-quality suggestion of “so MeTaPHoRiCal CanNiBAliSM durr-hurr” honestly all jokes aside, it's not a taboo that even slightly unnerves me. This may be more of an anthropology question but I was curious how certain civilizations developed a cultural taboo pertaining to cannibalism. If cannibalism served a medicinal, spiritual (etc. Because why not. In my opinion, the natural repulsion to cannibalism is a learned evolutionary mechanism. 45M subscribers in the AskReddit community. i’m not like fucking Jeffrey Dahmer or anything like that, but if you’re in a situation where it is absolutely necessary to consume human meat then it shouldn’t be “gross”. 3) Is eating an Awakened Animals (and things comparable to them) cannibalism? Cannibalism is one of the big Taboo bad juju in today’s/most cultures. My point on the Kashrut is that if it was an extension of cannibalism taboo why then was it not actually talked about or expressly forbidden in the Kashrut. Many cultures considered cannibalism to be a taboo before prions we're discovered. In my opinion if some one has no belief in a soul then the body is just meat and there should be no problem. It doesn't matter whether the question is also philosophical, or religious, or law based. Taboo nature of this aside, would you face prosecution if you were to resort to cannibalism or “drawing lots” to survive a plane crash/being marooned on an island/ or had to survive orb a ship adrift and you were then returned to society. Cannibalism has been associated with diseases like Kuru, as well as the risk of blood born pathogens. We often think of taboo in terms of proscribed action: it’s taboo to marry your brother; or, in certain cultures, to eat pork. In Western society, eating the dead is ultra taboo, probably due to the influence of religion over the centuries and the way we exalt the dead. That is the point of this thread. I can see why the Guard as a whole would discourage that, although perhaps the Guardsmen wasn’t afraid of getting censured for eating human, but for obtaining that corpse in the first place. Kuru occurs because our brains contain prions that transmit the disease. If anything kids are even more useful because if you maximize their growth you can make each one a God pawn, something you otherwise get once in a blue moon. The reason for the act of cannibalism being taboo is the special place the human body holds in our culture. Crypto Depends on the culture. Same reason humans can't eat rotted animals on the side of the road, but vultures and maggots can chow down worry free. I think that it would make for interesting interactions. We eat other animals why not eat each other. Anyone can do it - so regulation would be difficult. . Some burial practices actually involve a lot of alteration and interference with a corpse, like mummification or embalming. If you read the Kuru text, you can see that it's done constantly as a form of mourning. 2. But I wonder how cannibalism would be… Serious, not trolling. The dark questions we all have. It’s never really revealed. There's been plenty of talk on the subject, but no official consensus reached. That is not typically a pet's purpose. Cannibalism was always taboo; it did not become so only with the dawn of Christianity. 516K subscribers in the halloween community. Cat too. This is the CMV classic opening! "If you ignore the following reasons why my view is wrong, my view is not wrong. Thats why there are diseases tied to cannibalism, because we never made the evolutionary strides to eat each other. It's not bad unless you don't use a condom if it's like brother and sister kissing it's fine people just think eww I would never kiss my sister but if you have legitimate sex then it can be bad for the child because you are sibling and you have the same genes so in the prose's somthing happens with the identical genes and it gives the baby some bad stuff like autism down syndrome and the other "Cannibalism is the act of consuming another individual of the same species as food. Elven nobility, or the human tribes of the Western Forests, or some other group in your world might think about a) what "cannibalism" means--whether it's eating members of your own family, your own species, or any sentient; b) whether cannibalism is taboo, or is instead Is it that the person has to be there? Or be dead for a few millennia 1st? However, that argument loses water when you consider the remote tribes that practice cannibalism. It could also be seen as desecrating a corpse, which is generally frowned upon by common morals across most cultures. Cannibalism is usually associated with murder and death. Perhaps you too will one day be able to enjoy the taste of human flesh. "Cannibalism" is derived from the Carib people. Lizardfolk are mentioned as eating the bodies of humanoids- which is still cannibalism but that just isn't a taboo in their stereotypical culture (same as there are examples of cannibalism not being taboo in human cultures) Instead, find a suitable subreddit (e. Here's my personal take on why it works so well in horror So many other popular themes in horror, such as zombies, vampires, werewolves, demons etc, are fun and scary in films, but don't actually exist in real life. I think Cannibalism should be a more accepted thing in culture. The other answers to this question are good examples of what your e. Not that I do it, but assuming a person were dead from natural causes (disease-free), what, exactly is wrong with eating them?… Cannibalism is a taboo practice almost everywhere (apart from relatively few cultures historically, where is mainly ritual), but happened anyways. Yes, there are health risks from eating other humans, but that isn’t the primary reason it’s taboo; it’s because we think eating other people is gross and wrong. Veganism isn't a practice without justification. I’m not sure if this is 100% true, but incest is often referred to as the universal taboo by anthropologists because almost if not every society has an incest taboo Posted by u/flyflooon - No votes and 1 comment That's not why we're against being cannibals. Specifically, Jun 21, 2018 · Cannibalism, to these writers, was the worst taboo. reReddit: Top posts of February 1, 2019. It's a completely natural… 23M subscribers in the explainlikeimfive community. There's a good biological reason why cannibalism is taboo in virtually every culture: Eating other humans can make you sick. Oct 9, 2024 · jump to content Apr 4, 2017 · But most of all, cannibalism deals in taboo. Generally cannibalism is considered to be the act of eating one’s own species. ) But sexual crimes are way more taboo and "mature" while even little kids play shooting games. One thing that always comes up in any conversation about cannibalism - not that it comes up OFTEN in my circles, I just want to clarify - is that cannibalism is bad for the health of whoever or whatever is partaking. In some cultures ritual cannibalism was and is practiced to take parts from the dead person into you to ensure their life after death. The reasons below combine to make regular cannibalism either explicitly illegal or at least a strong taboo across most cultures: Empathy & attachment People aren't likely to eat their deceased friends or family because it feels wrong (due to human empathy and the association between one's physical body and personhood). But it feels like that people who part take in cannibalism are universally shamed--even in times of desperation, famine or… Cannibalism seems to have served as a way to check and affirm peoples loyalty, and bears some similarity to traditional communal feasts. It's possible that now, one could do it safely, but the taboo remains. People are hungry, that’s wasteful Also think if the people who have a compulsion to eat human flesh- if they could just legally buy fetus wouldn’t that be better? And although cannibalism is a heavy taboo, it really isn't that uncommon at all. 4K subscribers in the Macabre community. Cats and dogs are our pets, and we at least in the US place that into a special category that puts it above the status of livestock. Veganism: A philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude—as far as is possible and practicable—all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose; and by extension, promotes the development and use of animal-free alternatives for the benefit of animals, humans and the environment. funny that it (the anti-cannibal argument) turned from general cannibalism to only cannibalism of infants. A world that accepts cannibalism would learn so many cooking secrets. He explores many other symbolic aspects of taboo, and how it sets a cornerstone for society to exist. They died naturally/weren't murdered for their meat. Posted by u/Allegretta - 32 votes and 57 comments (1) Cannibalism is a recent (relatively recent) taboo, and a thoroughly western one. Kuru is one such disease. This seems to be true for animal cannibalism too like in the case of Mad Cow Disease. Also, we do monitor the cattle population for Cannibalism is pretty much a terrible course of action for mammals to take, in regards to continuity of their respective species. The humanoid Draccona would be considered cannibalism, the few nonhumanoid sapient dragons may or may not be considered cannibalism, but actively killing them would be considered murder. r/AskReddit is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions. As for desecration of a corpse, why are we using the appeal to majority?. 43M subscribers in the AskReddit community. Posted by u/Skye_is_the_limit - 12 votes and 41 comments Kuru is a brain disease, but I don't think that's related to the fact that most instances of cannibalism in the western world are committed by some of the less stable individuals. In the shinobi world, frankly, nobody cares for killing. Cannibalism for survival is well documented, and the random selection part is common too, but nobody has ever started hacking into their live friends as a better alternative. Cannibalism, killing, torture, etc. I'd say cannibalism is wrong for a variety of reasons. Accepting cannibalism also sort of accepts blamming of your fellow soldiers, assuming you run out of corpses eventually. In our world, I think, if you asked somebody about whether they'd commit cannibalism if there was no other option while a huge taboo and disgustingmost people I know would probably consider the act of killing someone just to eat them, worse than the act of cannibalism themself. And so people might associate healthy human meat with farming humans, which makes sense from a healthy cannibalistic standpoint. I just don't see any reason why someone should not be allowed to donate their body to a cannibal or necrophile if they so desire, but because of laws that say you can't desecrate a corpse, it is outside the law. Even before germ theory was a thing. We eat livestock because that's its purpose. Anthropologically speaking, cannibalism blurs the lines of what it means to be human, and that's deeply unsettling. It was even practiced in Europe at various points in history. Yeah, let me simplify my comment a bit more for you. Compare China with, say Europe and India would be extremely interesting, in my opinion. Whereas cannibalism is essential only in biomes with no soil. Many prehistoric bones from Europe and Asia show sign of cannibalism, but most Eurasian cultures have taboos on cannibalism. Humans who consume human meat will get prions in them that fuck you up. So the question you have to ask are whether or not different 5e races are considered to be different species. Prions are a major concern. Finally, legalising cannibalism would open new culinary opportunities. I remember watching a doc maybe ten years ago where a journalist stays with an indigenous community (i'm not completely sure where) where they ate their deceased as a form of respect. If I could safely eat dragon, sure, why not. Edit: Some background: Armin Meiwes worked as a computer repair technician, and at the age of 40 Meiwes posted an advertisement on the website The Cannibal Cric (EDIT: actually called the Cannibal Cafe) which is a forum for people with a cannibalism fetish. There are two main kinds of vegan: Those who absolutely abstain from animal products which are taken without the consent of the animal (the deontologist); and those who abstain from animal products on a contingent basis, typically when the animal product is obtained by a harmful practice which results in negative net utility (rule All of these films ponder the link between loving someone and feasting on them, between cannibalism and kinks and body modification. You're thinking specifically of kuru, which was spread through ceremonial cannibalism. Human meat and organs carry human pathogens, i. Not every culture, but a lot, have burial/disposal practices about honouring the dead and a taboo around interfering with the dead outside of cultural practices. Who knows, perhaps the ultimate taboo won't be taboo for much longer. Prions. With cannibalism there is risk of contracting serious and deadly brain disease from the consumption of human flesh. Many descriptions of diablerie compare it cannibalism in regard to how it is viewed in larger vampire society. Yet, I understand why the taboo is there. " I mean the title says it all. I hope you can find Freud's approach to the subject of Taboo to be interesting. No, I'm not a cannibal. I was also wondering if any sources recorded why it was taboo so early in developed civilizations. If you don't think the fact that there is a scientific reason why dogs are friends for humans rather than meals is a good argument, then I don't see how there ever could be something that could change your mind. Why is it human cannibalism is taboo ? Here's a look at the cultural and symbolic taboo around human cannibalism. Cannibalism requires no expertise. If cannibalism did exist in certain religious cults, such as Orphic Dionysian ritual – and again, I stress that we cannot confirm that it did – then it was certainly relegated to theses cultic practices alone and was not part of the greater fabric of Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. Rape is actually way more common in the US, especially if you include sexual assault. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. If you are caught committing cannibalism, you'll be sent off to a rehabilitation facility located in either Eisenie or Kuiper depending on what continent you live on. 267K subscribers in the morbidquestions community. And, let's not forget, one of these films is available on Disney's own streaming service. Specifically, eating the brain of another human being can cause kuru — a brain disease that's similar to mad cow disease. " Defining cannibalism as eating a sentient means that, assuming one doesn't see a mouse as sentient, a mouse isn't a cannibal for eat their own kin, and etc. This may be part of the reason why cannibalism is a taboo in nearly all cultures. Business, Economics, and Finance. That's outside the comic, but in the narrative it translates as something almost taboo because of how much it avoids it. Cultural taboo. So it seems like it's one of those practical rules turned dogmatic, like Jews not eating pork. Why is it considered taboo to harm dogs and cats but not the same for other animals For context we put chickens, pigs, and cows through horrible conditions in the slaughterhouse and slaughter them for food and no one cares but if we did the same for dogs or cats people would lose it, why don’t we treat other animals the same? My pet peeve was that they kept talking about cannibalism as the ultimate taboo, but then provided a bunch of exceptions to it, proving the taboo isn’t consistent or universal. Got this from Vox. Macabre, the grim or ghastly aspect pertaining to death; the allegorical representation of the dance of… Why is it human cannibalism is taboo ? A look at the cultural and symbolic taboo around human cannibalism. Why is this the case, and why are some species able to indulge in cannibalism on a regular basis with seemingly no adverse effects? I'm not sure eating people really is seen as more dangerous than eating beef, and if it is, the reason is probably that people like to point to reasons that performing taboo behaviors is a bad idea, and also because the example of widespread cannibalism leading to endemic disease is so widely known. Instead, humans have developed various rituals around death and the handling of human remains that reinforce communal bonds and respect for the individual. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; Oct 31, 2017 · Cannibalism became increasingly taboo in modern history, as mainstream religions have typically frowned on the practice, labeling it as barbarous and driving it almost to extinction—while It is not my dream to be able to walk into a high end cafe and order a human heart off the menu. ? (i know some cultures may practice cannibalism but I believe on a whole it is taboo. There are accounts of cannibalism in various amounts of places where malnutrition is an issue. There are two types of cannibalism: homicidal cannibalism, the act of killing someone to eat them, and necro-cannibalism, the act of eating someone who is already dead. Well, in any really… I want to discuss a society where cannibalism is part of the culture and is seen as normal. There might be a couple health risks associated with it, but in reality there are health risks associated with most things we consume. Greek mythology has a number of cannibals whose cannibalism makes them villains. Add that to Christianity and Judaism where it’s important to keep the body intact and you get the knee-jerk reaction to the very mention of As for the proximate question of why you and I personally think cannibalism is wrong, you get the unsatisfying answer that many have pointed out here - it's the norms of the society we are currently living in. Mind you that the ritualistic eating of human flesh is very different from a diet that is composed of human protein. ) purpose, then it becomes more complicated w/r/t an understanding of cannibalism, and subsequently why cannibalism might not be practiced in a similar way in larger cultures (because, if these two levels of cultures, tribal and any more complex form of society, are actually somewhat similar Cannibalism is frowned upon for mainly cultural and religious reasons, and social norms. I dunno, it's above my pay grade to say what's worse and why. It’s so taboo to talk about cannibalism but it’s really not that bad. My first question was: but why? Potential Reasons: Religion: This one easy to use but it feels too Right, murder is a weird one. one of my preferred examples of this was with the native Americans who believed in a monster called the Wendigo which was a man eating monster/evil The taboo against cannibalism is nearly universal – and it generally ranks as one of the worst sorts of taboos to violate (recognizing that some cultures have ritual cannibalism of the dead as a form of the process of grieving and deposition of the corpse or when dealing with fallen opponents in warfare, but that is a different kettle of human, er, … Topic question: Question for Atheists: Why is Cannibalism Immoral? reply: I don't think cannibalism in and of itself is immoral. Prions mean that if you cannibalize human flesh, you'll likely get sick and die yourself eventually. g. It would be cheaper than a funeral and it might even be a way to “sell your body” before you die and get some sort of benefit out of dying. Completely. Personally I think it's nasty and taboo, but I think you can make a good argument for it if: The person you are eating consented to it. There are many cultures where "culinary" and/or "ritualistic" cannibalism were practiced. Cannibalism is a casual part of life in this culture, with no taboo surrounding it at all, and a necessary part of honorific conduct during wartime. disease causing agents, so there's that much more of a chance of catching something dangerous from eating human flesh as opposed to eating another species. It is not unhealthy for humans to eat humans, so long as it's properly cleaned and prepped, except for the brain matter, which can transmit a disease that rots your brain and can't be cooked out. I never understood the taboo around cannibalism for aren't we all just meat anyway, an animal which is no lesser than us as a species would consume the flesh of their family without a though and surely it would make sense from both a utilitarian view and in the sense that there is no closer connection one could have with another. Expand user menu Open settings menu. You said it's moral to eat people, and since babies are people it's in the same category. That’s why we have little to no quarrels about eating animals. But, as if that's not enough, there is another reason. It's obvious why the former disturbs people, but why is the latter taboo? Iirc, you can get severely ill from cannibalism, so a cultural taboo was formed to prevent people from doing it. And there have been societies that engaged in cannibalism. It is a well established fact that cannibals are excellent cooks. And there are plenty of ritualistic killing/cannibalism and just people who Why is there a taboo about eating dead humans but not other animals or even dead things depending how you view picked fruits, vegatables, ect. So in my game anyone who might be classified as a person is probably also going to fall under the “cannibalism” label if you eat them, even if there’s no biological or Ergo, it would still be cannibalism if an elf ate the flesh of a dwarf. Obviously, it has to do with "taboo", which is why behavioural scientists haven't reached a consensus on whether cannibalism is an indicator of mental issues per se. That doesn't necessarily mean it was frequent , humans most likely were never a staple food for any culture. It's nature's way of avoiding cannibalism. Reddit . Many Feb 17, 2015 · There’s a good biological reason why cannibalism is taboo in virtually every culture: Eating other humans can make you sick. Same reason I think eating dog and horse is gross, but eating lobster and pig is delicious. But in a much deeper sense, the word ‘taboo’ denotes the very points where the sacred and profane converge: sexual intercourse, the taking of life, childbirth. In my world, there's a certain culture group on a northern continent that is all about cannibalism. Cannibalism however is a concept that sounds like it should only be found in Generally for as long as civilised societies have existed, acts such as cannibalism (or uncontrolled cannibalism) have been classed as taboo for many different reasons such as safety, religion etc. 818K subscribers in the creepypasta community. Can't find anything about cannibalism being the cause of prions. It has been (or is) practiced on every continent, most famously the Americas and the Pacific. are all stigmatized topics. g: r/NoStupidQuestions) and ask "why is cannibalism taboo? aren't we letting meat go to waste?". Cannibalism is taboo but this is way, way beyond the taboo into the unthinkable. Wasn't there a guy on reddit who ate his own foot? I mean that's technically cannibalism. I could see your argument for “metaphorical cannibalism” if Jesus was dead, but Christian’s believe he’s alive. e. Learning from that, a fantastical society doesn't need to have the taboo over cannibalism, but if it does, it would probably revolve specifically about the dominant race or the culturally important race in the society. Even when we take murder out of the equation, we tend to stress a respect for the dead. I think you may have missed what I was questioning, I was not questioning if cannibalism was 'taboo' but if that taboo is what lead to kosher laws. I honestly don't understand why people think cannibalism is so bad we are animals and 95% of animals commit cannibalism. I hope I don't have to explain why murder is bad. Why not have a plain example of cannibalism? That doesn't count the zombies which are basically not troll either. Secondly the cannibalism often seems to have been somewhat symbolic, notable here is the fact that a majority of those killed had their hearts and livers extracted and eaten. As much as cannibalism can help you survive, so can kids, in rimworld. And your perspective also brings into question "What is sentience?" which has been defined as: For artists, writers, gamemasters, musicians, programmers, philosophers and scientists alike! The creation of new worlds and new universes has long been a key element of speculative fiction, from the fantasy works of Tolkien and Le Guin, to the science-fiction universes of Delany and Asimov, to the tabletop realm of Gygax and Barker, and beyond. (Although maybe physical assault or attempted murder events out the numbers. There's nothing inherently morally wrong with it, at least in my opinion, but there you go. That’s why, that’s the embedded emotional reaction. Besides there is no need to, at least here in the US. Obviously there are societies that have existed with it, but it's not a crazy thought to think that over the lifetime of a culture, it would not be hard to go from "It's okay to eat people after they die if they want to", to "It's okay to eat people after Possibly the easiest answer to the question "why it cannibalism taboo in so many cultures" is "it's not". r/Creepypasta | A place for fans of Creepypasta stories, images, and more. I wonder if the discomfort around it has religious roots. dgoysv txam ttx cyvmo jitv rkqxmbk hcinl bzpsd exhx ylee